Skip to main content

India-Pakistan Feud That Now Lasts For Decades

Over 10 years ago, Christian Parenti brought up quite a tense conflict between India and Pakistan in his book “Tropics of Chaos”. And even though the book itself was published in 2011, the roots of this rivalry go way deeper than one might expect.
            Everything started because of the countries’ need for water – a region called Kashmir was rich with alluring rivers, and since Pakistan’s agriculture almost entirely (in 90% of the cases) was dependent on rivers, it was crucial for them to add Kashmir to their territories  ("Tropics of Chaos", Christian Parenti). Originally, Kashmir was mostly inhabited by Muslim people but was ruled by a Hindi governor, so the situation in the region was far from being stable, and the state wanted to join neither Pakistan nor India. However, Pakistan decided to act - in October 1947 they sent the troops to take over the region. India didn’t want to give up such a water-rich asset, sending their warriors as well - and that’s how the rivalry started. As a result, after hundreds and hundreds of dead soldiers, the Line of Control was established, but no final border was in place ("A History of Kashmir Conflict"). However, this was just the beginning.
Kashmir on the map
(https://images.app.goo.gl/SGm2KMiZdx2DFYjV6)
            In 1965, as well as in 1999, the countries went to war over Kashmir again. Pakistan simply couldn’t give up on one of the most valuable regions for the economy, and India wanted to have the power. At some point, the countries even came to a treaty, allocating rivers to each other’s territories, but once India started to restrict water flow to Pakistan, the fights broke out again.
            At the same time, climate change was also taking part in this conflict – it was simply making everything worse ("Tropics of Chaos", Christian Parenti). Pakistan reported dangerous “over-exploitation of groundwater” and a decline in rainfall. Due to extreme environmental changes, Pakistan is losing water which is already such a scarce resource for the nation. If this trend continues – and it will if humanity doesn’t decide to act upon it – Pakistan’s entire economy will collapse.
Pakistan's in a water crisis
(https://images.app.goo.gl/VunRFJA8BkQJD7w2A)
            Today, in 2021, the rivalry still goes on. Even though a fragile cease-fire was established between the countries since 2003, shooting regularly occurs across the Line of Control. In addition to that, in all of those cases, it’s impossible to understand who started it – both sides claim to be responding to the attacks of the other (Global Conflict Tracker).
            Citizens of divided Kashmir are not living their best life as well. India-administered side of the region has enacted lockdown, leaving thousands of people detained and without connection to the outside world. Other than that, an attack on an Indian convoy in February 2019 also resulted in the deaths of at least forty soldiers which was considered “the deadliest attack in Kashmir in three decades”. The countries continue to fight, conducting airstrikes on each other’s territories, shooting down military aircraft, and capturing hostages (Global Conflict Tracker).
India-Pakistan: Latest news on Kashmir crisis
https://images.app.goo.gl/n69qhrKLokuLG7ry9
            Finally, both countries have their reserves of nuclear weapons. So far, we might have just been lucky that a nuclear war hasn’t broken out yet between India and Pakistan, as by this stage in the dispute everyone’s walking on thin ice. Water scarcity aggravated by climate change has brought the two countries into desperation over the years. The US and other developed countries have to act on this conflict much more actively because if we don’t do anything now, no one knows what might happen in the future.

Comments

  1. This was such a fascinating read. It truly is awful what the conflict between Pakistan and India has come to. It's scary to think that even a nuclear could erupt from this. This really shows that climate change is a serious matter and something that needs to be dealt with properly. Great post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The fact that water scarcity and the greediness of holding resources against each other is truly awful. The fact that we as humans could keep something so valuable as water away from other people is disappointing to say the least. To add salt to the wound, we throw nuclear freaking weapons into the mix. Truly sad! Nice post, Anna Maria.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Solid! I agree with your conclusion! We do need to act. Chaos from dwindling water resources and intense animosity with the neighbor is a recipe for world war or an opportunity for world cooperation. Thank you for pointing out the need for world action. I hope more recognize opportunity, we are running out of those.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It still continues to amaze me that countries cannot figure out how to work together. And therefore haven't been able to figure out that the only way to survive the climate crisis is to work as a team. Fighting like this does nothing but make things worse.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really enjoyed reading your blog post. Something I found interesting was that refugees of both Pakistan and India are travelling to the opposing country. Hindu and Sikh refugees are moving from Pakistan to to India, and Muslim refugees are moving from India to Pakistan. Other than that, the nuclear war aspect scares me. Hopefully the two countries never resort to that because it would surely kickstart the end of the modern world.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You're an awesome writer, Anna-Maria! I loved reading your post.

    It's difficult for me to understand why different countries fight so much. Why can't there be more sharing culture rather than violence?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A post-failed state: what happens next? - A Kyrgyzstan Case Study

A post-failed state: what happens next? - A Kyrgyzstan Case Study

Even the "mascots of drought" are being taken out by climate change

   The Leptoptilos Crumenifer, commonly known as the Marabou Stork, is widely known in Africa -- its home. Briefly written about in Christian Parenti's book, Tropic of Chaos , the Marabou Stork is said to be the "mascot of drought" (Parenti, pg. 61). While travelin g to Garissa, Parenti came across "massive flocks of them perched everywhere" and refers to them in a matter that paints them to have a sole purpose of eating the marrow from the bones of the cattle killed by the drought. However, Marabous have a much bigger purpose and are not simply the "mascots of drought". They are, however, being taken out by climate change and biodiversity loss in Africa. Leptoptilos Crumenifer, or "Marabou Stork" is sometimes referred to as the unofficial national bird of Uganda.     With the urbanization and building of more cities all over Africa comes a huge loss of ecosystems and environmental homes to so much wildlife. The drought that Parenti talks abo

Poppy Production in Afghanistan

According to Parenti’s Tropic of Chaos, Afghanistan produced 90% of the world’s opium population in 2011. How are they able to do this? By growing and selling poppies. The best environment for poppies to germinate is in an area with a significant amount of dry soil and daylight. Parenti states, “...poppy uses only one-sixth the water needed for wheat.” As climate change is increasingly becoming worse, the high temperatures and droughts for Afghanistan are becoming worse. However, this is a huge benefit when it comes to planting and producing poppies. Although poppy production is increasing with drought, it’s not an invincible plant. Yes, it uses less water to germinate and grow, but extreme droughts can prevent this from happening at all. According to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime ( UNODC ), cultivation had a 32% increase and poppy production had a 10% decrease in 2022 due to the droughts. The efforts of farmers are increasing while the results are not what they are hopi